
Compare supplier quotes before they become your tender price
Build your bid on costs you can explain. Put each supplier’s offer on the same basis, resolve the gaps and give your reviewer a clear record of the decision.
Three quotes arrive just before your pricing review. One supplier quotes per box, another per item and a third includes delivery without saying whether unloading is covered. Choosing the smallest total now could leave you pricing different things.
For an estimator preparing a tender, the useful question is: “What will it take to supply the required item, in the required quantity, to the required place and time?” A short comparison record helps answer it before the number enters your tender price.
Start with one comparison brief
Use the relevant specification, drawing or scope reference to write down exactly what you need. Keep the reference and version beside the quote request. Include the required quantity, unit, delivery point, timing and any installation, testing or documentation that must be included.
If a supplier offers an alternative, record it separately. Do not silently treat a substitute as equivalent. Ask the responsible technical reviewer to check it against the tender requirements and use the buyer’s clarification process where needed.
This is a workflow for assessing your own supplier inputs. It does not replace the tender’s evaluation rules or authorise you to change its requirements.
Separate a missing answer from a zero cost
Give each field one of three practical states: confirmed, excluded or awaiting clarification. A blank delivery charge should stay unresolved until the supplier explains it. If an item is excluded, identify who will provide it and obtain a supported cost before treating the offer as complete.
| Compare | Record | Clarify when |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Exact item and specification reference | The offer changes a material, model or service |
| Units | Pack size, required quantity and number to order | A box, set or length has no defined contents |
| Price basis | Currency, tax treatment, quantities and discounts | Totals use different bases or conditions |
| Delivery | Destination, freight, unloading and timing | A quotation says only “delivery included” |
| Validity | Expiry date and conditions for holding the price | Your likely order date falls outside the offer |
| Payment | Deposit, milestones and due dates | You cannot fund the proposed timing |
For general supplier selection, the Australian Government’s business.gov.au supplier guidance recommends considering reliability and delivery alongside price, and documenting scope, payment and delivery terms. These are useful commercial considerations; that guidance is not South African procurement law.
A worked example: the lowest unit price is not the whole comparison
Fictional example for arithmetic only: your internal comparison brief calls for 120 identical items delivered to one location. The technical reviewer has confirmed that both offers describe the same item. All amounts below are illustrative rand amounts on the same tax-exclusive basis; they are not market prices, quotes or a recommendation about tax treatment.
| Cost or condition | Supplier A | Supplier B |
|---|---|---|
| Offer | R480 per box of 10 | R50 per item |
| Quantity required | 12 boxes × 10 = 120 items | 120 items |
| Goods subtotal | 12 × R480 = R5,760 | 120 × R50 = R6,000 |
| Confirmed delivery charge | R450 | Included |
| Comparable subtotal | R6,210 | R6,000 |
| Delivery timing | Confirmed for required date | Awaiting written confirmation |
| Decision state | Ready for wider review | Clarification needed |
A’s R48 goods price per item looks lower than B’s R50. Once the confirmed delivery charge is included, A’s comparable subtotal is R210 higher. That does not automatically make B the right choice: its delivery timing remains unresolved.
Ask B to confirm the date before deciding. Keep the clarification with the quotation. If B cannot meet the requirement, review the available options with the tender owner instead of hiding that uncertainty inside a low total.
The subtotal is only the supplier input in this example. It is not a complete tender selling price: other project costs and your pricing decisions still need separate review. Do not copy this example’s exclusions into a real tender.
Check when the price and the goods will actually be available
Read the quotation’s validity conditions against your expected order date, not only the tender submission deadline. If the offer may expire before you can order, ask for written confirmation of what can be held and on what terms. Record an unresolved validity gap for the tender owner to decide how to address.
Ask what starts the delivery clock: an order, payment, approval of drawings or another event. Record the promised destination and whether the supplier has confirmed the required quantity. “Available” without a date or quantity is not a useful handover to the person planning delivery.
Review payment timing separately from the headline price. A deposit may require funds before your customer pays you. Ask the person responsible for finance to review the proposed commitment. A clear comparison should show that condition, even when it does not change the quoted subtotal.
Make clarifications easy to answer
Send a short, numbered request that refers to the supplier’s quotation and the relevant line. For example:
For quote [reference], line [number], please confirm the pack contains 10 of the specified item; the total covers 120 items; delivery is to [location]; and the required arrival date is [date]. Please identify any exclusions and confirm how long this price remains valid. If anything changes, please issue a revised quotation with a new date or revision.
Use one owner for each outstanding answer and an internal reply deadline that leaves time for review. Keep the original quotation as well as the revision. Update the comparison from the confirmed answer, then recheck any totals or assumptions affected by the change.
Hand over a decision someone else can follow
Before transferring the chosen cost into your pricing work, record the selected quote reference, revision, comparison basis, remaining conditions, reviewer and review date. Retain the reason for the choice. “Cheapest” is incomplete if the offers differ in scope or timing.
A simple spreadsheet is adequate when the comparison is small, one person owns it and the supporting quotes are easy to retrieve. Keep that approach if it works. When several people chase changing quotes across multiple bids, review how you organise requests, answers and approvals before choosing software.
Download the supplier comparison record and use it on one upcoming package. Your immediate goal is a price input with its assumptions visible.
For the next step, explore TenderProSA’s supplier RFQ management page and assess it against your team’s actual quote workflow. Bring a representative package and ask how its scope, revisions and outstanding answers would be handled.